In the break between innings, TNT showcased a couple of the other sports on offer for the princely sum of £29.99 per month. We started with men’s netball (or “basketball” as I believe our American friends call it) before being treated to five minutes of Ultimate Fighting. At least… I think it was Absolute Fighting – it was someone getting the absolute pulp beaten out of them – so come to think of it, it might just have been a repeat of the last 20 overs of England’s first innings.
The day started well enough for England, with Ecclestone wrapping up the Indian tail, taking a catch off Lauren Bell to dismiss Deepti, before bagging the wickets of Renuka and Rajeshwari Gayakwad. The general consensus among the media and commentators seems to be that Ecclestone was poor yesterday, and Lauren Bell appeared to agree with this in the press conference, presumably indicating that Ecclestone herself wasn’t happy either; and I agree she wasn’t at her best, but still… even if slightly off-song, where would England be without her?
As India had the previous day, England lost two early wickets. The first of these was exactly the one you predicted, but given that India are now a batter down (Satheesh Shubha has a broken finger) I think it evens things up generously that England also have someone in their top 3 who is unable to bat. Heather Knight joined She-Who-It-Is-Genuniely-Starting-To-Feel-Unfair-To-Name back in the dugout, but then Nat Sciver-Brunt and Tammy Beaumont looked to be digging in and things started to feel like they were getting back on track. Not “comfortable” entirely, but not dreadful.
I’m in two minds about the Beaumont run out. The editor of this site spoke for many:
And I sort-of get that, but… England needed to be positive, and there was a single there – TB is one of the sharpest runners in the game, and even though there was a critical moment of hesitation, she would still have made it if it wasn’t for an absolutely exceptional pick-up and throw from Pooja, swooping like an osprey on a juicy pike. It was the fielding equivalent of getting an unplayable delivery, and sometimes you just have to take that on the chin and say well played.
It did mean though the England were just one wicket away from turning a drama into a crisis, and inevitably with Wyatt’s wicket the game was probably up. Amy Jones lasted about as long as you’d expect. (Don’t believe me? Believe Alyssa Healy, who was caught on the stump mic at Trent Bridge saying something to the tune of: “Why does she always do this?”)
And then England’s long, long tail came home to roost, with Sophie Ecclestone coming in at 7. Ecclestone won’t thank me for saying it, but she is a tail-ender. A very handy tail-ender, but a tail-ender nonetheless, and once the ball started spinning, neither she nor anyone else had any answers. It was carnage, with more turns than the Monaco Grand Prix, as England collapsed so hard I had to make on-the-fly changes to my charting code!!
With England on the floor, and a second back-to-back Test match for India to play next week, surely they would enforce the follow-on and finish the job asap? But no! They seem to have decided ahead of time that they weren’t going to use the follow-on, so… they didn’t. Even in these exceptional circumstances, when they could have had the game done and dusted in two days.
Because, as subsequent events suggest, they almost certainly would have had England at least 6 or 7 down, which is where they themselves got to, as England’s spinners turned the tables in the afternoon. The 3 specialist seamers between them bowled just 8 overs, taking no wickets, whilst Ecclestone and Dean did the hard yards – 34 overs for 6 wickets, 4 of them to Dean, whose ability to be able to turn the ball (something (for all her brilliance) Ecclestone doesn’t usually do too much) meant that England could claim to have decisively won that afternoon.
There is, of course, absolutely no chance whatsoever of them winning the game.
But at least they won the afternoon on Day 2.
And Lauren Bell remains undismissed in Test cricket.
I think they call that: taking the positives.
Lovely article Sid. I tittered away as I was reading it. Needed cheering up after today’s second session. That was seriously painful to watch!
LikeLike
Well!
On my first viewing of the teamsheet I thought the batting ends at 5 or 6!
Then there are still places for poor old Dunks , still out of form, thrown into a cauldron of opening a test match of 4 days when she has found it tough to bat for 40 minutes on this tour. But they still select her, i think that is cruel.
Although I am not aware of who could come in her place apart from the obvious which you have mentioned Syd! You know better than I who is sitting in the wings who could try and occupy the crease.
Have they a select list of bodies who may still be around from the training group or are they all home now??
And finally, protect Ecclestone she could burn herself out.
LikeLike
Poor old Dunks still out of form and put in to open in a 4 day test when she has struggled to bat for 40 minutes on this tour. And the tail did not wag, firmly tucked between the legs.
The selection seems odd to me
LikeLike
Well that’s it then, England just about done on this tour. Terrible team selection again, why pick all those pace bowlers for an Indian track that was bound to be spin friendly? Even if Glenn is injured another spinner should have been picked. And I can’t believe Dunkley is anywhere near Test cricket right now. Don’t think I’ve ever seen a player so obviously out of sorts for so long! It must go down as bit of a coaching failure.
But I think the media (not here though, well done guys for keeping it real) have made way too much about this whole “England can’t play spin” business. It’s a turner in Mumbai! Did they expect a pitch from Perth to have been dropped in? (I think Jon Lewis must have, but that’s a whole ‘nother story). England have some of the best spinners, so it’s usually our opponents who have trouble playing spin. My only caveat would be England didn’t try sweeps quite as much as they could have today. But this isn’t the first and it won’t be the last side to come to India and struggle against spin.
But we just have a real problem playing India in tests in general – never seem to perform well, and India’s less hectic approach is more suited to the format. Deepti finally found a format she can excel in, after being pretty average in T20s for a few years now. Can’t understand why India didn’t enforce the follow-on (unless they knew the pitch was about to seriously fall apart!) Surely they would have things nearly wrapped up by now and could use the extra day’s break! Now England might as well try and dig in to frustrate India and draw things out a bit. But they probably won’t.
Moan over. Let’s move on. Can India repeat the trick against the Aussies? Will be interesting to see.
LikeLike