OPINION: The Under-19 World Cup Should Not Be An Under-19 World Cup

The ICC have reaffirmed their commitment to holding an Under-19 Women’s World Cup, with the tournament now rescheduled from its original window at the tail-end of 2021, to January 2023.

As is always the case, you can argue that it should have been done sooner – the first men’s edition was held in 1988, and it has been a biennial feature of the calendar since 1998 – but we are where we are, and the important thing now is that it is being done!

With a firm(ish) date now agreed, thoughts immediately turned to who might play, with Indian journalist Snehal Pradhan tweeting:

Having Shafali on the team would clearly put India among the favourites to reach the final, alongside Australia, who will be able to field a squad full of seasoned WBBL pros, who will obviously be odds-on to win the tournament.

But we also need to remember that this is supposed to be a “development” competition. By January 2023, Shafali will likely have 50 caps, and be as automatic a pick in India’s full ODI team as she is currently in the T20 format, whence all of her 22 caps to date have come. She doesn’t need “developing” now… let alone in 18 months time!

The tournament regulations have yet to be firmed up, but in my view the “Under-19” label should be just that – a label,  not a law. The tournament should exclude anyone who has a full international cap regardless of age, and also allow space for a limited number of players over the age of 19, with perhaps one wildcard pick up to 21 and another up to 23.

It could then play out similarly to last year’s Rachael Heyhoe Flint Trophy in England, where the unavailability of the England players for most of the tournament actually created the most exciting and competitive domestic season in recent memory.

If the Under-19 World Cup is serious about being a “development” competition, then that is what it needs to be… even if that makes it not technically an “Under 19” World Cup.

3 thoughts on “OPINION: The Under-19 World Cup Should Not Be An Under-19 World Cup

  1. Agree mostly – but maybe five caps not one – to allow those who have dipped their toe in on the international stage but are not quite ready that extra opportunity to develop,

    Like

    • Anita has made exactly the point I was going to make! I think a ‘zero cap’ moratorium would just be slightly too restrictive, and five caps seems about right to me.

      Like

  2. The trouble with your argument is, for mine, I can’t quite work out what the problem actually is, and what is it trying to achieve.
    Are you saying:
    1- Australia being dominant and most likely winning said tournament impedes the development of other players and teams? Or
    2- Other teams need the chance to win the tournament to develop?
    If it’s 1, my response would be that surely you will develop much more effectively playing against the best teams and players? At junior and senior levels. Otherwise why have we all argued for years that the big teams should play against lesser teams more frequently
    If it’s 2 then surely winning a tournament without Australia (and maybe England) in it is automatically devalued if it is labelled as any kind of World Cup. The accusation will always be that you’ve only won it by default. It’d be like winning the men’s rugby World Cup if the All Blacks weren’t in it or the Women’s Hockey World Cup within the Netherlands.
    It honestly reads like making a problem that isn’t really there just because it’s ‘unfair’ that Australia is currently the dominant team and had more money, resources etc. (And currently is the crucial word. It won’t always be so)
    Seems a bit odd to actually sort of punish a team and country for properly resourcing women’s sport…. I mean it’s not like England and India in particular don’t also have loads of money in cricket they could reallocate to a similar level

    Like

Have Your Say...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.