This week on the CRICKETher Weekly:
This week:
A huge last 3 overs struck by Nat Sciver-Brunt and Alice Capsey lifted England above 300 for the first time in an ODI since 2022, when they crossed that mark 3 times – twice against South Africa and once against the West Indies.
With 47 overs gone, England were 255-5, and 300 looked out of reach. NSB was on 94 off 108 (a Strike Rate of 87) and Capsey on 23 off 33 (SR 70). But in the remaining 18 balls, Capsey hit 16 off 9 (SR 178) and Sciver-Brunt 30 off 9 (SR 333), adding 47 runs in 3 overs to finish on 302-5. This isn’t quite a record – for example, India scored 62 from their last 3 overs against England at Canterbury in 2022 – but from the data on Cricsheet* it appears to be the 4th most runs scored in the final 3 overs of an ODI in the professional era; which gives you an idea of the scale of it.
NSB’s hundred – her 9th in ODIs – draws her level with Tammy Beaumont and Charlotte Edwards for the most ODI centuries for her country. It wasn’t her most fluent ton (though how good a player do you have to be, to have “bad” hundreds?) but starting with the two consecutive ramps for 4 that brought up the milestone, followed in the next over by consecutive 6s off Diana, it was an innings with the explosive ending of a superhero movie that will live long in the mind’s eye. At last, England were entertaining and inspiring, if only for 15 minutes.
Prior to that, England’s innings had followed a familiar pattern from this tour – decent numbers that you felt slightly flattered the actual performance on the field. Tammy Beaumont was clearly struggling with her timing, so what possessed her to then try a ramp – a shot that is invariably fatal if you don’t time it perfectly – will remain a mystery up there with how they built the pyramids, or why anyone bought “that” Ed Sheeran single**.
Was TB playing her last match for England here? My guess is not – I think she’ll play against New Zealand, and will also captain the team in Ireland in September; but only because the thing that should happen, won’t.
As I tweeted somewhat controversially, it feels like the time has come for Heather Knight to call it a day in ODIs. Her innings here of 12 off 17, with just one 4 off a streaky inside edge that could have gone literally anywhere, just looked tired more than anything; despite the fact that she passed on WPL and didn’t play much regional cricket leading into this series. Given that Knight isn’t going to play against Ireland anyway, I think the time is now to hand over the baton before the New Zealand series.
There are clear reasons not to give the captaincy to any of the “obvious” candidates. Nat Sciver-Brunt doesn’t appear to want it; and nor does Amy Jones. Sophie Ecclestone isn’t in the frame, or she would have retained the vice-captaincy; and Charlie Dean would create selection issues because she isn’t England’s best spinner, meaning you totally eliminate any flexibility with your spin options – you’d have to pick both her and Ecclestone for every game.
Which brings us to Grace Scrivens! No, she hasn’t played a match for England; but she is an absolutely exceptional leader and cricketing brain, as England acknowledged by making her England A captain aged just 19. It would take an extraordinary player to make her debut as captain against New Zealand next month, but I believe she is up to it, and will be a fantastic captain to lead England through the next 10 years – Scrivens should replace TB opening the batting and take over the captaincy now. It won’t happen. But it should.
Anyways… Jack Rule on Twitter called this suggestion “absolutely insane“, and he’s right! But what can I say? We are where we are, thanks to England’s refusal to engage with any succession planning; so insane is what we’ve got – embrace the madness Jack, it’s all we’ve got left!!
(Oh… and for the record, I believe Heather Knight should retain the T20 and Test captaincies over the winter; though Scrivens should play in the Tests as vice captain.)
Back on the field, England still had some formalities to complete to win the series, and Pakistan acquiesced in familiar fashion – they kept up with the rate for the first 15 overs, but having lost 3 wickets in the powerplay they didn’t have the engine-power to keep it going, stuttering before ultimately suffering yet another late-order collapse to defeat by a statistically huge margin. Muneeba Ali did her bit with 47, and Aliya Riaz chipped in with 36; but it never felt like Pakistan were going to chase 200, let alone 300.
England didn’t bowl brilliantly, but partly because they didn’t really have to. Sophie Ecclestone did however achieve the record everyone has been talking about – the fastest player ever to take 100 ODI wickets… as long as you count only matches where she actually bowled! (A definition of the record we should acknowledge that some dispute.)
Ecclestone said afterwards that she wanted to win trophies – specifically the Ashes and a World Cup – rather than break records. I instinctively feel like the fans will agree with her there; and I believe it will happen for her too. But perhaps no longer under this captain.
————
* Caveat – Cricsheet is great… and (and I’m not gonna lie, this bit is quite important!) free… but it isn’t quite complete.
** Insert literally any Ed Sheeran single here!
This week:
I had a friend at Essex University who hailed from Derby. A couple of weeks into her first term, she finally lost her temper at some poor guy who had been the umpteenth person there to mistake her for a Northerner. “I’M FROM DERBY,” she yelled, with caps-lock fully engaged. “IT’S IN THE MIDLANDS!”
And unsurprisingly, she wasn’t wrong – this part of the country has been known as the Midlands (or “Middel Lond”) since the late middle ages; and having driven past it on our way to Leeds (very-definitely in The North) last weekend, I can confirm that Derby is indeed pretty-much “in the middle” of England.
Coincidentally, “in the middle” is also an apt description of England’s performance at the County Ground in Derby today.
Let’s start with their batting performance in the 1st innings, having been inserted by Pakistan, who (correctly) believed that their only hope of victory was to bowl England out cheaply and chase a low total.
The average 1st innings score in an ODI between the ICC Championship sides since 2018 is exactly 250. England’s score today? Just shy of 250 – 243, to be exact – bang in “the midlands” of that grey area on the Ghost chart which indicates a typical score. Not only that, but you’ll rarely see a straighter line on on a chart – England plodded-along at between 4 and 5.5 an over for the whole of their innings, never really slowing down, but never taking off either.
During the innings break, a few people commented that England seemed to have played-out a lot of dots – about 26 overs of them. But this too was totally average. It varies a lot (between 30% and 69%) but England’s average dot percentage in their last 40 ODIs is 50% – so 52% today was… you’ve guessed it… right in the mid-lands!
The batting scorecard was also unusually balanced. Here are England’s batters, with their scores expressed as a percentage of England’s total – all but one in the teens, with no one batter dominating – England’s highest score being Alice Capsey’s 44.
| Tammy Beaumont | 14% |
| Maia Bouchier | 7% |
| Heather Knight | 12% |
| Nat Sciver-Brunt | 13% |
| Alice Capsey | 18% |
| Amy Jones | 15% |
Come the 2nd innings, the wickets were also shared around – 2 for Cross, Bell and Dean, and 3 for Ecclestone – as Pakistan made a decent effort in their chase, although somehow they never quite looked like winning.
Pakistan stayed in touch through the first 30 overs, winning that 20-30-over phase; and our Win-Her Win Predictor actually had them at 58% to win the match at the half-way point in the 2nd innings. I didn’t publish it, because it felt “wrong”, but the numbers are nonetheless what they are – a team that is over 40% of the way towards their target, still with 7 wickets in hand as Pakistan were, wins the game more often than not.
Part of the reason Pakistan were able to maintain their rate was the helpful contribution of a whopping 40 extras (mostly wides) to their total. This definitely was not the mid-lands from England’s perspective – indeed it was closer to Aberdeen! In the last 40 ODIs England have conceded an average of 14 extras per bowling innings, with the recent worst (prior to today) being the 28 they gave up to the West Indies at the World Cup in New Zealand in 2022. Both Bell (7 wides) and Cross (5 wides and 2 no balls) ended up bowing an entire additional over as a result of their prolificacy, with both (unusually in Cross’s case, less unusually in Bell’s) struggling to adapt to the left-right combination after Muneeba Ali came in.
Pakistan didn’t quite have enough fuel in the tank to get to the chequered flag, but this was their best performance of the series. Their issue is that unlike some of the other 2nd-tier sides, they don’t have that one batter – a Hayley Matthews or a Chamari Athapaththu – who will nip them the extra 30-or-40 runs they fell short today. Find her, and they actually could be in business.
A crowd of 7,500 watched England beat Pakistan in the final T20 at Headingley, to seal a 3-0 series whitewash against the women in green.
A few folks seemed a tad disappointed with that crowd figure – apparently just over 10,000 tickets had been sold, plus “comps” (“complementaries” – tickets given away for free) so Yorkshire were hoping for 12,000, and it was a beautiful day in the West Riding, but despite the sunshine nearly 2,500 people bought tickets they didn’t use.
Nonetheless, at about 40% capacity, Headingley still felt pretty full – there were no huge empty spaces in the stands – and for a minor (and, let’s face it, pretty uncompetitive) series that feels pretty good to me. If we’re getting that for a dead-rubber against Pakistan, I reckon we are doing okay from a commercial perspective – not every series can be The Ashes.
On the field, Danni Wyatt put on a show, and looked all-but set to become the first full-member player to score 3 international T20 centuries. (It has been done twice by players from associate nations – shout out to Fatuma Kibasu of Tanzania, who scored her hundreds against Mali, Qatar and Eswatini; and Esha Oza of UAE, who did it against Oman, Qatar and Bahrain.)
With the help of some woeful Pakistani fielding (she was dropped 3 times) Wyatt made it to 87 off 48 balls before holing-out; and she did the right thing to keep pushing – given that there were still 6 overs left, the selfish option would have been to slow down and ensure she got the century, but there was clearly no thought of that in her mind.
Wyatt’s heroics meant that England powered through the middle overs, hitting at more than 10-an-over between overs 7 and 16. They didn’t have quite such a good death phase, losing 5 wickets for 33 to be all-out off the final ball; but arguably the perfect T20 innings is one where you max-out your resources, leaving nothing in the tank. The 174 that England made was by a distance the highest total of the series, and well in excess of a “typical” 1st innings score in a T20 between the ICC Championship teams.
It was certainly far too much for Pakistan, but at least on this occasion they didn’t collapse in a heap. Despite bowling their opponents out twice in this series, I don’t think England have been at their best with the ball. As I discuss on this week’s CRICKETher Weekly, recorded at Headingley before the game, outfield catches are cheap wickets for bowlers, and arguably should be discounted, as they are in what is increasingly seen as one of baseball’s key pitching metrics “FIP” – Fielding Independent Pitching. I’m not genuinely expecting cricket to suddenly change the way it calculates a bowler’s figures, but I do wonder if it is worth considering something like FIP as a supplementary metric?
England’s inability to take wickets when the opposition aren’t literally giving them away like they’re Maundy Money at Easter, has to continue to be a concern. Of course, they were without their main strike bowler today, which didn’t help. Her replacement got the ultimate vote-of-no-confidence from the captain of not bowling the opening over, but to be fair to Heather Knight, her lack of confidence looked entirely justified – she was all over the place, and how she only went at a rate of 6.25 from her 4 overs, I’ll never know. As one swallow does not a summer make, one decent ball per over does not an international fast bowler make, and England must be praying that Lauren Bell will be able to play every match when it really counts in the World Cup and the Ashes next winter.
I’ll be writing Wisden’s round-up of this series in the next couple of weeks, and cricket’s publication of record will document that England won this T20 series with some ease; but there will be caveats. Wyatt’s innings today, and Amy Jones’s keeping in the match at Edgbaston, were the highlights, but were they oases in the desert, or just mirages on the horizon? We’ll find out when the sterner tests come around later this year and next.
This week:
Pakistan slumped to a series defeat at Northampton, losing their last 5 wickets for just 8 runs as England turned in a thoroughly professional fielding performance, holding on to 7 outfield catches, leaving Amy Jones for once with little to do behind the stumps but twiddle her gloves, following her “4fer” in Birmingham.
After the early departure of Danni Wyatt, Maia Bouchier and Alice Capsey combined to give England what looks on the scorecard to be a decent enough start – 48-1 at the end of the powerplay; but 42% of those runs had come in just one 20-run over, which was probably the least convincing 20-run over I’ve ever seen.
Capsey was on 2 off 9 balls at the start of the 4th over, and looking… it has to be said… somewhat at sea, much as she had at Edgbaston. The over then began with Capsey dancing down the pitch and getting a big edge which passed just out of reach of the diving keeper – 4 runs, which could have easily been another early bath. Then two more thoroughly unconvincing, baseball-style clubs into the leg side, but nonetheless bringing a brace more 4s. A defensive push straight back to the bowler somehow also found its way through to the boundary, and then after a dot off the 5th, finally a much more convincing shot off the final ball for another 4.
At that point it felt like the switch might have flicked, and we were relishing the prospect of Capsey finally producing that really big innings for England that her talent has always promised; but it wasn’t quite to be – she disappeared back into her shell again, scoring just 9 runs from the next 18 balls she faced, before being caught behind, and then… just to really rub it in… stumped for good measure, to end things.
Capsey did joint-top-score, and also go on to take 2 wickets as Pakistan committed hara-kiri, winning her player of the match. But she’s into her 3rd summer of international cricket now, and after playing 28 games for England, she averages little more than Charlie Dean, with Dean averaging 19 at a Strike Rate of 108, and Capsey 22 at a Strike Rate of 123. It’s better. But not as better as it ought to be. And yes, to bend George W Bush’s quote, she is suffering from what you might call “the hard bigotry of high expectations”, but if she wants to be the best, she has to do better.
Nat Sciver-Brunt’s 31 looked a lot more authoritative, but it took another very decent cameo from Dani Gibson – 18 from 9 balls – for England to get up to the kind of score that would have given them something to bowl at against most other opponents.
Of course, they didn’t need those runs today, with Pakistan folding as they did, but one day they will, and if Gibson can nail-down that “finisher” role for England, it would be a huge win for JonBall. The other side of that coin however is that when Nat Sciver-Brunt is unable to bowl, which is becoming an increasingly regular feast in the liturgical calendar of English cricket, Gibson probably isn’t the right player to take on a full bowling role in her stead.
It is a headache that even Lewis’s famous AI might be ill-equipped to cure, and you get the feeling from the way the bowling changes proceeded today that Heather Knight knows it too – it felt like she was trying to hide Gibson’s overs where no one would notice, which isn’t an ideal starting-point for your 5th bowler. And maybe that too is the hard bigotry of high expectations, but we aren’t playing softball any more. This team has been given resources that previous generations could not even have dreamed about – our expectations are high, but theirs should be higher.
This week:
It’s been an up and down few months for Pakistan in T20 cricket. The ups: clean-sweeping South Africa 3-0 at home; and beating New Zealand 2-1 away. The downs: a 2-1 away defeat to Bangladesh; and most recently a 4-1 loss to West Indies at home – the latter essentially a 4-1 defeat to Hayley Matthews, who won 3 Player of the Match awards in the 5-game series.
Their failure to take anything much from a one-woman Windies team at home didn’t bode well for their chances against England, who for all their flaws remain indisputably one of the top 3 sides in the world, albeit that their 2nd-placed ICC ranking (ahead of India in 3rd) probably flatters them a little.
The one advantage the Pakistanis did have over some of the England XI coming into this game, was that they had played some recent cricket, with the West Indies series having wrapped up less than a fortnight ago. Contrastingly, two of England’s brightest young stars – Alice Capsey and Lauren Bell – have played a combined total of zero games between them since England returned from New Zealand over a month ago. There was rust on both of them, and it showed.
Capsey got off the mark with an edge off the back of her bat, which somehow missed the stumps and went past the befuddled keeper for 4, and… it didn’t get any better from there. With England having lost a 2nd wicket in the meantime, Capsey needed to knuckle down; instead, she played the kind of shot that looked like she’d just closed her eyes and swung, with all-too-predictable consequences.
Bell also started poorly, her first over going for 12 as Gull Feroza went on the attack up-top for Pakistan. Bowlers do of course get second chances that batters don’t, and Bell got her revenge on Feroza with a decent ball in her second over, with the help of a brilliant catch from Amy Jones. Bell also added another couple of wickets as Pakistan collapsed, giving her final figures of 3-22, which don’t read too badly; but she definitely didn’t have the control today that she showed on the New Zealand tour, and which England will need from her if they are going to challenge for the T20 World Cup.
Ultimately, none of it mattered in terms of the outcome of this match. England had enough depth and experience to recover from 11-4 to post 163. Amy Jones and Heather Knight were dealt a difficult hand with the situation they found themselves in, but they played their cards with all the nous of a pair who have over 450 caps between them.
In this, they were ably assisted by some terrible fielding from Pakistan – Nida Dar just couldn’t get her placements right – everything England hit seemed to find a gap, and when it didn’t, it found a misfield.
Having dug in in the early-middle phase, England were then able to accelerate and maintain a pace of 10+ over for the remainder of the match. Knight and Jones’ stand meant that Dani Gibson could come in and add a very useful 41 not out at the death, to take the game out of Pakistan’s reach. (It doesn’t feel like a coincidence that Gibson is one of the ones who has been playing regional cricket, batting herself back into form with a half-century for Storm at Bristol last week.)
Pakistan made a decent start to their chase, and by the half-way mark were on-track to win the match, according to our new toy – a win-predictor called “Win-her”, which is based exclusively on data taken from women’s cricket.
Of course, Win-her turned out to be very-much not correct in terms of the outcome of this game, but that doesn’t mean it is “wrong”. What it is saying is that a team that has made a decent dent in the chase and only lost 3 wickets at the 10-over mark in the chase, will mostly go on to win the match.
And Pakistan should have! But where England used the late-middle phase to explode, Pakistan imploded, losing 5 wickets for 10 runs and handing the game to England, leaving 12,000 fans to go home happy on the opening day of England’s international summer.
CRICKETher 