OPINION: The Specialist’s Lament

A very unusual scene unfolded at Eastcote Cricket Club last Sunday. In a 50-over Women’s County Championship match between Middlesex and Surrey, Middlesex skipper Izzy Westbury moved the field.

Leaving an enormous void on the leg side between backward square leg and long on, she packed the off side with attacking fielders, including a short (if not quite silly) mid off, and a slip and a gully just inches from the bat.

Such an aggressive field might not have looked out of place in an Ashes Test, but in a Women’s County Championship game it felt unprecedented, because 99% of the time the captain has to guard against “that” ball – the one which you know is coming, once or twice an over – the one that is pitched too short, or not pitched at all, or which slides down the leg side. And when it does come, a field like that leaks runs you can ill-afford; so the skipper plays it safe – square leg, midwicket, mid on – hoping to build pressure by saving runs – defence as a form of attack.

Westbury’s daring move – attack as a form of attack – was made all the more so because Middlesex were defending a lowish total (165) against an opposition batsman (Bryony Smith) who looked well set on 23 off 36 balls. Yet it was possible because the bowler was Alex Hartley – perhaps, with the retirement of Holly Colvin, the one bowler left in the county game who you can rely on not to bowl “that” ball.

That Hartley’s action puts one in mind of a ballerina reaching for a pirouette, is somehow appropriate, because for all the grace of the performance, what lies behind the execution is an iron will and an obsessive sense of discipline, to which few care to aspire and fewer still achieve.

So Westbury was able to set the field with a rare confidence in her bowler… and was rewarded with two wickets in two balls, both caught at gully as pitch-perfect deliveries turned away from the right-hander – a special moment, made possible by a special bowler.

But sadly “special” still comes at a price – Hartley bats at 11 even at county, where England tail-enders usually consider themselves all rounders; and she has to be hidden in the field, so they say. Thus when England needed to fly a spinner out to the Women’s World T20, they turned elsewhere – to a “steady hand”, who can “bat a bit”; who “turns the odd one”… but better keep that midwicket in there, just to be on the safe side.

And who is to say it wasn’t the right decision? England’s batting was fragile! They did need shoring-up in the field! So they demand excellence in two of the three disciplines – bat, ball or field – and brilliance in one is not enough any more.

Pragmatically, it makes sense; but romantically, there is still a longing for a bygone age, when a specialist… could just be special.

Book Review: The Girls of Summer by David Tossell

The Girls of Summer is not the book that David Tossell – a veteran author, with a shelf-full of sporting chronicles to his name – wanted to write. When we first met him at the start of the 2015 summer, he happily admitted that he was hoping to tell the story of a triumphant victory; not the humiliating failure of which the reader can’t fail to be aware as they dash through its 300 pages.

And dash you will! Though his “day job” these days is in PR for American Football’s NFL, Tossell clearly remains a newspaper man at heart; and one who really knows and loves his cricket. His prose zips along, hot off the back page, taking you to the heart of the action on the field, as balls are belted and stumps are struck, in the kind of intimate detail that only a full-length book affords.

Tossell’s great coup is to have negotiated access to the dressing room. Sitting on the balcony beside the coaches gave him the opportunity to document a unique perspective on the game which definitely felt out of reach to the rest of us at the time – the coaching staff’s reluctance to engage with the media having become something of a running joke in the press box by the end of the summer.

Bestriding it all is the figure of the “Head of Performance” – Paul Shaw. Shaw comes across as something of a tragi-comic character, hiding behind his buzzwords and his flip charts, while ultimately refusing to accept any responsibility for the defeat, insisting right to the bitter end that he is the brilliant man manager let down by the failure of his players.

At one point Charlotte Edwards laments: “We didn’t play our brand.” And somehow this actually gets to the heart of the problem with Shaw’s regime, laid so bare by the view from Tossell’s window – that Shaw had instilled in the players the need to play “a brand”… while Australia were busy playing cricket.

If there are any flaws in The Girls of Summer, they are twofold.

First, Tossell’s occasional reluctance to directly confront the most difficult questions. For example, he clearly knows why Danni Hazell was (inexplicably, in the eyes of the Aussies who couldn’t believe their luck) left out of the early engagements of the series. He even hints obliquely at the reason, but somehow can’t quite bring himself to cast real daylight upon what has to be seen as one of Shaw’s most controversial decisions.

Second, if you were hoping to come away with some real understanding of the players as “people”, with lives and loves beyond the narrow confines of the game, then you are going to be sorely disappointed by The Girls of Summer, as it (with perhaps one-and-a-half exceptions) draws a coy veil across the idea that they might even have such lives, let alone loves.

Nevertheless, setting such quibbles aside, The Girls of Summer is a book that every women’s cricket fan… indeed, every cricket fan… needs to read – a subtly devastating glimpse into Paul Shaw’s bizarre “bubble” of management speak, motivational memorandae, and A PowerPoint for Every Problem which promised everything that summer… and delivered nothing.

MATCH REPORT: Hartley The Hero As Middlesex Mash Surrey

A Fran Wilson half century might have been the dominant entry on the scorecard on a sunny spring day at Eastcote CC, but it was actually a pair of cameos from Alex Hartley which turned an otherwise well-balanced game into a one-sided walk in the park for Middlesex.

Put into bat, Middlesex lost Dunkley (3) early, playing on as she tried to cut Nat Sciver, but Tash Miles and Fran Wilson rebuilt, taking the score to 47 before Miles (14) became the first of Cecily Scutt’s five victims. Wilson looked to push on, dominating partnerships with Anna Nicholls (3) and Beth Morgan (7) to take them to 102-4.

However, the collapse that followed was one of which England would have been proud, as Middlesex lost their next 5 wickets for 11 runs, including a magnificent catch by Sophie Pout to dismiss Wilson for 63, leaving them on the brink at 113-9, with only Alex Hartley to come.

Hartley is a self-confessed “tail-ender” and initially looked quite the part as a couple of streaky edges went through the vacant slip area; but as she grew in confidence, she began to find her shots as her and Naomi Dattani put on 52 for the final wicket – not only changing the course of the game, but grabbing a potentially crucial extra batting bonus point as they passed 150.

In reply, Surrey were soon under the cosh as Middlesex’s overseas, South African-born New Zealander Holly Huddleston, bowling with real pace and good length, removed Kirstie White (3) and Nat Sciver (5) cheaply. Surrey continued to lose wickets at regular intervals, but nevertheless at 70-5, with Bryony Smith well set on 23, a victory still felt like a possibility until Hartley intervened once again.

Changing ends, looking for the ball to turn with the slope, Hartley and skipper Izzy Westbury set an attacking field with a slip and a gully, and were rewarded with two wickets in two balls – both caught by Westbury at gully. Suddenly there was no way back for Surrey, and they subsided to 99 all out, as Middlesex celebrated what could prove to be a very important 17-point win.

Afterwards, Alex Hartley told CRICKETher: “I’ve been working over the winter on my role as a tail-ender, getting off strike and getting the ‘in’ batter back on strike. I felt a bit of panic when I came in – I’ve never been in that situation before, coming in with 22 overs to bat – but I just had to play my own game and today it came off – my highest score!”

Kia Super League: Thunder & Lightning Are Twop of the Twitts!

The Kia Super League might still be 3 months away, but off the pitch the battle is already hotting-up online between the marketing teams of the five* Twittering franchises hosts.

As a bit of fun we’ve powered-up the super-computer, run the big numbers, and calculated a sophisticated(!) “Impact Score” for each of the five* official Twitter accounts. (List here!)

Team Followers Tweets Impact Score
Lancashire Thunder 1,084 353 382,652
Loughborough Lightning 679 237 160,923
Yorkshire Diamonds 1,247 66 82,302
Southern Vipers 751 49 36,799
Western Storm 605 43 26,015

It’s early days of course, but already it is looking like Lancashire Thunder might have this one sewn up… unless Loughborough Lightning can pull something out of the bag? Or perhaps it will be Yorkshire Diamonds making a late run for the (ahem…!) Twitle?

More seriously though… kudos to the folks at Lancashire and Loughborough. The Super League will only be a success over the longer-term if it connects with the fans and Twitter is a great way of making that happen – keep up the good work guys!

————-

* Surrey don’t have an independent “Surrey Stars” Twitter account, so we’ve put them aside for the purpose of this analysis!

Kia Super League Squads – Facts & Figures

Age Old Questions

  • The average age of a KSL player is 24.
  • Lancashire Thunder have both the oldest (Laura Newton, 38) and youngest (Sophie Ecclestone, 16) players.
  • Southern Vipers are the oldest team (average age 25).
  • Lancashire Thunder are the youngest team (average age 23).

Counting The Counties

  • Sussex, Yorkshire, Kent and Lancashire have the most KSL players – 8 each.
  • Of the D1 counties, Staffordshire have the fewest players – just 2 – Eve Jones and Steph Butler.
  • Aside from the overseas players, three players didn’t play county or other top-level cricket in 2015 – Laura Newton, Arran Brindle and Rosalie Fairbairn (née Birch) – in the latter two cases, due to maternity.

Role Play

Based on the player’s primary role for the current county or country, there are:

  • 35 bowlers.
  • 25 all-rounders.
  • 22 batsmen.
  • 8 wicket keepers.

NEWS: Full Kia Super League Squads

Lancashire Thunder

  1. Kate Cross (EW)
  2. Sarah Taylor (EW) (Capt)
  3. Danielle Wyatt (EW)
  4. Sarah Coyte (O)
  5. Deandra Dottin (O)
  6. Hayley Matthews (O)
  7. Sophie Ecclestone (EWA)
  8. Emma Lamb (EWA)
  9. Ellie Threlkeld (EWA)
  10. Natalie Brown
  11. Georgia Holmes
  12. Laura Marshall
  13. Natasha Miles
  14. Laura Newton
  15. Nalisha Patel

Loughborough Lightning

  1. Georgia Elwiss (EW) (Capt)
  2. Rebecca Grundy (EW)
  3. Amy Jones (EW)
  4. Beth Langston (EW)
  5. Sophie Devine (O)
  6. Ellyse Perry (O)
  7. Dane van Nierkerk (O)
  8. Evelyn Jones (EWA)
  9. Alex MacDonald (EWA)
  10. Georgie Boyce
  11. Thea Brookes
  12. Amy Gauvrit
  13. Lauren Griffiths
  14. Sonia Odedra
  15. Paige Scholfield

Southern Vipers

  1. Charlotte Edwards (EW) (Capt)
  2. Natasha Farrant (EW)
  3. Lydia Greenway (EW)
  4. Suzie Bates (O)
  5. Sara McGlashan (O)
  6. Megan Schutt (O)
  7. Georgia Adams (EWA)
  8. Ellen Burt (EWA)
  9. Katie George (EWA)
  10. Arran Brindle
  11. Isabelle Collis
  12. Daisy Gardner
  13. Alice Macleod
  14. Fi Morris
  15. Carla Rudd

Surrey Stars

  1. Tammy Beaumont (EW)
  2. Laura Marsh (EW)
  3. Natalie Sciver (EW) (Capt)
  4. Rene Farrell (O)
  5. Marizanne Kapp (O)
  6. Meg Lanning (O)
  7. Sophia Dunkley (EWA)
  8. Alex Hartley (EWA)
  9. Bryony Smith (EWA)
  10. Aylish Cranstone
  11. Grace Gibbs
  12. Cordelia Griffith
  13. Raveena Lakhtaria
  14. Beth Morgan
  15. Kirstie White

Western Storm

  1. Heather Knight (EW) (Capt)
  2. Anya Shrubsole (EW)
  3. Fran Wilson (EW)
  4. Lizelle Lee (O)
  5. Rachel Priest (O)
  6. Stafanie Taylor (O)
  7. Freya Davies (EWA)
  8. Sophie Luff (EWA)
  9. Amara Carr
  10. Jodie Dibble
  11. Rosalie Fairbairn
  12. Georgia Hennessy
  13. Sophie Mackenzie
  14. Cait O’Keefe
  15. Izzy Westbury

Yorkshire Diamonds

  1. Katherine Brunt (EW)
  2. Jenny Gunn (EW)
  3. Danielle Hazell (EW)
  4. Lauren Winfield (EW) (Capt)
  5. Alex Blackwell (O)
  6. Beth Mooney (O)
  7. Shabnim Ismail (O)
  8. Hollie Armitage (EWA)
  9. Steph Butler (EWA)
  10. Alice Davidson Richards
  11. Teresa Graves
  12. Katie Levick
  13. Anna Nicholls
  14. Laura Spragg
  15. Katie Thompson

NEWS: Warwickshire Sign England’s Gunn

England’s Jenny Gunn has followed Danni Wyatt out of the door at Nottinghamshire, making the move across the Midlands to Warwickshire.

Notts were relegated from Division 1 of the Women’s County Championship at the end of last season; and an exeat was therefore expected as their England players seek to maintain a high standard of domestic cricket.

In 10 seasons at Notts, Gunn scored nearly 3,000 runs at an impressive average of 46 (helped by a fair few of Not Outs) and took 83 wickets, including her domestic career-best 5-3 against Kent last season.

The signing is a massive boost for Warwickshire, who have been to the brink of relegation themselves a number of times recently, but have acquired the useful  knack of somehow clinging on.

NEWS: BCCI Claim ECB Did Not Invite Indians To Super League

UPDATE: See here for the ECB’s response.

This week’s announcement of the overseas stars for the Kia Super League has become overshadowed in the eyes of some Indian fans by an apparent row between the ECB and the BCCI over why no Indian players are involved.

The overseas contingent includes 7 Australians, 4 New Zealanders, 4 South Africans and 2 West Indians… but no Indians – much to the dissapointment of Indian fans:

The ECB had previously claimed to have contacted all the other boards offering their players the chance to participate.

But a spokesperson for the BCCI has appeared to contradict this, as Snehal Pradhan writes in India’s Firstpost:

“A senior BCCI official told Firstpost that they had not received any such communication from the ECB and that they could only consider allowing Indian players after they did.”

[Full Article]

Clearly, somebody is being disingenuous, but the question is… who?

UPDATE: See here for the ECB’s response.

UPDATE 2: This piece on Cricinfo makes it abundantly clear what the answer is to the above question!

LIVE: Kia Super League – Overseas Player Announcements

Follow this page for updates on today’s announcements!

6:15 – The England Academy player allocations will be announced next week. See you back here then!

17:30 – Interesting to consider whether these are the best 18 players in the world – or has it been more a case of trying to create well-balanced teams? No Alyssa Healy for example – did she lose out because of lack of space for another keeper?

17:20 – Richard Pyrah, Yorkshire Diamonds coach, suggests that his main criteria for picking overseas players was success in WBBL: “I wanted somebody who’s been there, done it and knows how to win.” He’ll no doubt be pretty chuffed to have landed Alex Blackwell.

10:20 – Were we expecting any Indian players to be part of KSL? Not really, if we’re honest!

10:15 – The ECB have certainly kept their promise that this will be “The Best v. The Best” – all of these teams now have their very own Ace of Spades – e.g. Loughborough (the one team without a “marquee” England player) now have Ellyse Perry!!

10:10 – In theory, South Africa are touring Ireland during the KSL window, and despite rumours to the contrary, the last we heard is this is still “on”, so we’ve no idea what this means for the South African players named today???

9:45 – Any massive surprises here? Not really! Perhaps we might have been expecting to see South African captain Mignon du Preez in there… but there is still one player yet to be announced!

Lancashire Thunder

  • Deandra Dottin (WI)
  • Sarah Coyte (AUS)
  • TBD
  • Kate Cross
  • Danni Wyatt
  • Sarah Taylor

Loughborough Lightning

  • Sophie Devine (NZ)
  • Ellyse Perry (AUS)
  • Dane van Niekerk (SA)
  • Becky Grundy
  • Georgia Elwiss
  • Amy Jones
  • Beth Langston

Southern Vipers

  • Suzie Bates (NZ)
  • Sara McGlashan (NZ)
  • Megan Schutt (AUS)
  • Charlotte Edwards
  • Tash Farrant
  • Lydia Greenway

Surrey Stars

  • Meg Lanning (AUS)
  • Marizanne Kapp (SA)
  • Rene Farrell (AUS)
  • Nat Sciver
  • Laura Marsh
  • Tammy Beaumont

Western Storm

  • Stafanie Taylor (WI)
  • Rachel Priest (NZ)
  • Lizelle Lee (SA)
  • Heather Knight
  • Anya Shrubsole
  • Fran Wilson

Yorkshire Diamonds

  • Shabnim Ismail (SA)
  • Beth Mooney (AUS)
  • Alex Blackwell (AUS)
  • Lauren Winfield
  • Katherine Brunt
  • Dani Hazell
  • Jenny Gunn

9:15 – Welcome to our Live Blog of the KSL overseas player announcements – we are expecting the news to start coming in at around 9:30am. We’ll start things off with some FAQs…

What’s being announced today? Which “overseas” players are playing for which teams – each of the six teams are expected to announce 3 overseas players. Note that “overseas” means non-EU players – the vast majority are expected to be from Australia, New Zealand, West Indies and South Africa.

How were the decisions made? We understand that 80 or so overseas players applied to be part of KSL and a big list was drawn-up which was sent to all the teams. The teams said which players they wanted, with the players also given the opportunity to express a preference, before ECB then made the final decisions.

NEWS: Surrey Defend Social Media Strategy

Surrey CCC have defended their social media strategy, following criticism yesterday that they appeared to have ignored the Kia Super League player announcements.

Surrey came under fire for their decision not to host a dedicated Twitter feed for Surrey Stars, and then for not Tweeting about the announcements during the morning, when there was a significant social media push from all the other teams.

However, Surrey’s Communications Manager Jon Surtees spoke to CRICKETher last night, assuring us:

“None of your concerns will be borne out over time. Indeed I hope we will be seen to be leading the way with promotion of the competition and our team.”

On the issue of the “joint” Twitter account, Surtees points to the other side of the coin: that it means they are able to leverage an existing social media presence with over a quarter of million subscribers across the various platforms – Twitter, Facebook, email, etc.. Indeed, a quick check on Twitter bears this out: the @SurreyCricket account has 46,000 followers… the other five “dedicated” KSL accounts have just over 3,000 between them!

And on the decision to hold off on social media promotion during the day, Surtees told us:

“Our Twitter and Facebook accounts have been ‘taken over’ with Stars branding and advertisements this evening – the time when our stats tell us our social media is most effective.”

Finally, Surtees promised that the women’s county team (which of course, is not the same thing as the KSL team, featuring mostly an entirely different set of players) would also benefit from an improved marketing presence this year.

With both the Stars and the “county” team scheduled to play games at The Kia Oval this season it will be interesting to see how this translates into “bums on seats”, and we certainly wouldn’t bet against them being among the best-attended matches of the summer.